
How to Answer “Why This Model?” Before Anyone Asks
Before your leadership team approves a manager development program, it will want to know which model the program uses and why. Have a plain answer to each question ready before the meeting.
When you propose a manager development program, expect the leadership team to ask which model it uses, and why that one. Before the meeting, prepare an answer on the research, and decide who will see each person's results.
The CFO and the general counsel have questions
Imagine you've proposed a manager development program, and the leadership team is supportive. Then the CFO asks whether the model is backed by research or just popular, and the general counsel asks who will see each person's results.
At a nonprofit, the questions may come from the board's program committee. Many of the people who run the organization's programs are part-time staff and volunteers, so the committee wants to know whether the model makes sense for them as well as for managers. It also wants to know whether the program will still be affordable in year three, after the grant that paid for year one runs out.
Is the model backed by research?
Ask the publisher for its research report, and read the summary yourself before the meeting. Look at how the model was developed and tested, and whether the publisher explains what the assessment measures and what it doesn't. Then write two or three sentences you can say out loud when the CFO asks.
Decide who sees each person's results
Before the program starts, choose whether each report goes only to the person, or also to their manager, and whether HR keeps a copy. Agree, too, on whether people in the same group will see each other's results, and whether anyone will compare one team with another.
Before you pick a model, look at its group reports. Some list each participant by name, and others show only a summary or patterns with no names attached. Choose the kind that fits what you've promised people, and tell people who will see their results before they take the assessment.
Then say plainly that the reports are for development. I should mention that I work with Everything DiSC®, so I'm not neutral here. Everything DiSC® is not, and should never be used as, a selection or evaluation tool, and the same rule belongs in your program whichever model you choose.
Find out what's in the facilitation materials
When you bring a program in-house, the facilitation materials are what your team will work from every time it runs a session, so find out what's in them before you choose a model. You probably won't get a copy before you buy, but the publisher, or a partner who sells the program, should be able to describe them clearly. Ask about four things:
How well thought through are they? A good facilitator guide lays out each session step by step, with timings for each part, so the facilitator knows what to cover and how long to spend on it.
Could someone on your team pick them up and learn them? Ask how a typical session is laid out and what a facilitator needs to know going in, then judge whether a person on your team could learn to lead it.
Can you adapt them? Some publishers expect you to follow their language, order, slides, and timing exactly. Others let you change the examples, shorten a session, or rearrange parts to fit your organization.
What comes with them? Look for slides, handouts, extra readings, and videos, and check which languages they come in. Some programs include most of what you need, some give you an outline and leave you to build the rest from scratch, and many fall somewhere in between.
The more your team has to build itself, the longer it will take before the program is ready to run.
Find out what training the publisher offers
Many publishers offer training for the people who will facilitate their programs. Some run workshops for facilitators, and some certify people as qualified to deliver the program. For some programs that training is required, and for others it's optional.
When it's available, it's worth taking, even when it isn't required. Your facilitator learns the content correctly the first time, which saves a lot of trial and error, and learns it alongside facilitators from other organizations, who can become people to call with questions later. Many of these programs also give your facilitator a credential they can take with them well beyond this job, and that can matter to the person you ask to lead the program. Ask what the training costs and how long it takes, and include both in your proposal.
Choose the person who will lead it
The leadership team will also want to know who on your team will run the program. Pick that person before the meeting, and be ready to say what experience they bring, why they'd be good at it, and why they want the role. Useful experience might be leading meetings, coaching managers, or running onboarding, and it helps if managers already come to them for advice. Someone who asked for the role will usually put in more effort than someone you assign.
People leave and change roles, so build for that from the start. Train a second person to co-lead, and keep the facilitator guides and notes somewhere the whole HR team can find them, so the program keeps running if your lead changes jobs.
HR should make the recommendation
Your HR team will live with the model for years, leading the sessions, answering managers' questions, and bringing it into onboarding. Because your team will run the program, HR should recommend the model and be ready to explain why. Take the time to choose well, even if the program starts a month or two later. In the masterclass, we'll look at how to build a program your own team can run. Save your seat here.
Join us on November 17 and 18
Your In-House Advantage is a free, live masterclass for internal HR, L&D, and OD leaders at organizations of 250 to 5,000 or more employees. It's two 90-minute working sessions, on Tuesday, November 17, and Wednesday, November 18, at 1:00 pm ET (10:00 am PT). In the first, we look at the patterns organizations fall into with new managers and what those patterns cost. In the second, you work on a solution for your own organization and leave with a one-page business case for your CFO.
It's live only, with no replay, and seats are limited. Nothing is sold in session one. In the last few minutes of session two, I'll explain how Symphony 100 works with organizations that want help.
Save my seat for November 17 and 18
Someone on your leadership team will ask, “Why this model?” Before they do, write down why you chose it, and check each reason against the publisher's research.
Frank November is the Founder & CEO of Symphony 100 and has been an Everything DiSC® Certified Practitioner since 2014. Symphony 100 Ltd. and Symphony 100 North America LLC are each independent, authorized partners of Everything DiSC® and The Five Behaviors®, which are registered trademarks of John Wiley & Sons, Inc., or its affiliated companies.
